From interest rates and market conditions to investment strategy, understanding what determines your returns can help you make more informed investment decisions.
Imagine two investors discussing their portfolios. One mentions an investment offering 18% per annum, while the other says theirs offers 15%.
At first glance, the choice might seem obvious. If one investment offers a higher return, why would anyone consider the alternative?
But what if the investments have different risk profiles, maturity periods, liquidity conditions or underlying assets? What if one offers a fixed contractual rate while the other’s return depends on market performance?
Suddenly, comparing 18% with 15% becomes less straightforward.
This raises an important question that investors do not always consider when evaluating opportunities: who actually determines how much an investment earns?
Is it the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), the government, the investment manager or the financial markets?
The answer depends on the type of investment, how its returns are structured and the economic conditions in which it operates.
Understanding these factors is essential because the rate you see when evaluating an investment does not always tell the complete story of what you will ultimately earn.
Who determines investment returns in Nigeria?
There is no single institution or individual responsible for determining returns across all investments in Nigeria.
Different investment instruments generate returns in different ways. Some have contractual interest or payment terms established when the investment is made. Others generate returns through changes in market prices, income distributions or the performance of underlying assets.
For example, the yield on a Nigerian Treasury bill is determined through the pricing and allotment process for the security, while returns on equities are influenced by company performance, market demand and changes in share prices.
For professionally managed investment portfolios, the outcome also depends on the assets selected, the investment strategy adopted, prevailing market conditions and the costs associated with managing the portfolio.
The distinction matters because two investments quoting similar annual rates may have very different characteristics and outcomes.
To understand why, it helps to examine how investment returns are determined across different instruments.
1. Fixed-income investments: When returns are established by investment terms
Certain fixed-income instruments provide investors with a defined framework for how interest or other payments will be calculated.
These include instruments such as Treasury bills, government bonds and some corporate debt securities.
However, even within fixed income, the way returns are calculated can differ.
A Treasury bill, for example, is generally issued at a discount to its face value. An investor pays less than the amount due at maturity, and the difference represents the investment’s return if the bill is held to maturity and payment is made as scheduled.
A conventional fixed-rate bond, on the other hand, typically makes periodic coupon payments based on a specified coupon rate. Its effective yield depends on the price paid for the bond, its remaining maturity and the expected cash flows.
Consider a simplified example of an investment offering a fixed simple annual return of 15%.
If an investor commits ₦1,000,000 for one year, the gross interest would be:
₦1,000,000 × 15% = ₦150,000
Assuming the agreed terms are fulfilled, the investor would receive ₦1,150,000 in total, before applicable taxes, fees and other charges.
This example illustrates a simple fixed-rate arrangement. Actual Treasury bill and bond returns may be calculated differently.
Importantly, the rate available to an investor depends on the instrument, its price, prevailing market conditions and the terms agreed upon at the time of investment.
An investor purchasing a government security today may therefore receive a different yield from someone purchasing a comparable security several months later.
The key distinction is that the terms of a fixed-income instrument help establish its expected cash flows, but the market influences the yield at which that instrument is priced.
There is also a difference between holding a fixed-income security to maturity and selling it before maturity. A sale before maturity may produce a capital gain or loss because market prices can change.
2. The role of the Central Bank of Nigeria in investment returns
One of the most common questions investors ask is whether the CBN determines the interest rates they receive on investments.
The short answer is that the CBN influences investment returns, but it does not directly set the returns on every investment product.
Through monetary policy, the CBN influences the broader interest rate environment, liquidity conditions and the cost of borrowing within the financial system.
One of its principal policy instruments is the Monetary Policy Rate (MPR), which serves as an important reference point for monetary conditions.
When monetary policy changes, it can influence money market rates, government security yields, bank funding costs and the pricing of other financial instruments.
For example, a change in interest rate expectations may affect the yields investors demand on newly issued fixed-income securities.
However, this does not mean every investment immediately begins earning a new rate whenever the MPR changes.
Existing fixed-rate investments generally continue to follow their contractual terms, subject to the conditions of the instrument. Newly issued securities, floating-rate instruments and investments with frequently repriced underlying assets may respond differently.
This is particularly important for Nigerian investors comparing Treasury bills, bonds, money market instruments and professionally managed investment products.
The CBN influences the environment in which investment returns are determined, while the pricing and structure of individual investments determine how that influence is reflected in actual returns.
3. Market-driven investments: When returns depend on performance
Not all investments offer a predetermined return.
Equities are a familiar example.
When an investor purchases shares in a company, the investment’s performance depends partly on how the market values that company over time.
A company may grow its earnings, expand operations or improve profitability, potentially increasing investor demand for its shares.
If the share price rises, an investor may realise a capital gain when selling. The investor may also receive dividends if the company declares them.
However, share prices can also decline due to weaker business performance, changing investor expectations, economic developments or broader market conditions.
Consequently, equity returns are not fixed or guaranteed.
Market movements also affect fixed-income securities, particularly when investors trade them before maturity.
For example, when prevailing market yields rise, the prices of existing fixed-rate bonds generally fall, all else being equal. When yields decline, existing bond prices generally rise.
This relationship is one reason investors need to distinguish between a bond’s contractual coupon payments and its market value.
For investment funds, returns depend on the performance of the underlying assets, the fund’s investment approach and applicable expenses.
The broader lesson is that the return an investor expects and the return ultimately realised are not necessarily the same.
4. What role does an investment manager play?
For investors using professionally managed portfolios or collective investment schemes, another important consideration is the role of the investment manager.
An investment manager does not independently control market interest rates or guarantee how financial markets will perform.
However, investment management decisions can materially influence portfolio outcomes.
These decisions may include selecting suitable securities, determining portfolio allocations, managing maturity exposures, assessing credit quality and responding to changing market conditions within the portfolio’s mandate.
For example, two investment funds operating within the same broad asset class may produce different returns because they hold different securities, maintain different maturity profiles or incur different expenses.
Their approaches to liquidity and risk management may also differ.
This is why evaluating an investment manager involves more than examining the most recently reported return.
Investors should consider the fund’s objectives, investment strategy, historical performance, risk profile, liquidity arrangements and fees.
Professional investment management aims to make informed portfolio decisions within an established investment framework. It does not eliminate market risk or guarantee a particular outcome.
At First Ally Asset Management (FAAM), this distinction forms an important part of helping investors understand investment opportunities in relation to their financial objectives and risk considerations.
Why do some investments offer higher returns than others?
Returning to the earlier comparison, why might one investment offer 18% while another offers 15%?
Several factors can explain the difference.
Risk and the possibility of loss
Investors generally expect compensation for accepting additional risk.
An instrument with greater credit risk, lower liquidity or more uncertain cash flows may need to offer a higher potential return to attract investors.
However, a higher advertised return does not automatically mean an investment is better, nor does taking greater risk guarantee a higher realised return.
An investor must consider the possibility of delayed payments, changes in market value or loss of capital.
Investment duration and liquidity
The length of time an investor commits funds can influence the available return, although longer investments do not always offer higher yields.
Interest rate expectations, liquidity needs and the shape of the yield curve can affect how different maturities are priced.
Liquidity is equally important.
An investment offering a higher rate may impose restrictions on early withdrawal or require an investor to sell an asset at its prevailing market price to access funds.
For someone who expects to need money within a few months, these conditions may be more important than a modest difference in headline returns.
Economic and market conditions
Inflation, monetary policy, government borrowing requirements, market liquidity and investor demand can all influence available investment returns.
In Nigeria, changes in the interest rate environment can affect the pricing of Treasury bills, bonds and other fixed-income instruments.
Currency movements may also affect the naira value of foreign-currency investments, creating additional considerations for investors evaluating returns across currencies.
Understanding these factors helps explain why rates change over time and why an investment opportunity available today may have different terms in the future.
Does a higher investment return always mean greater financial value?
Not necessarily.
An advertised annual rate is only one measure of an investment’s potential attractiveness.
Investors also need to distinguish between nominal returns, real returns and net returns.
A nominal return measures the increase in an investment’s value before adjusting for inflation.
A real return considers how inflation affects the purchasing power of that return.
For example, suppose an investment generates a nominal annual return of 15% while inflation over the same period is 10%.
Using the standard inflation-adjustment calculation:
Real return = (1.15 ÷ 1.10) − 1 = approximately 4.55%
In this hypothetical scenario, the investment has increased in nominal value by 15%, but its purchasing-power gain is approximately 4.55%, before applicable fees and taxes.
This distinction matters in an environment where inflation can significantly influence the value of future spending.
Net returns introduce another consideration.
Two investments with identical gross returns may deliver different amounts to investors after accounting for management fees, transaction charges, applicable taxes and other costs.
Compounding arrangements, distribution schedules and the timing of cash flows can also affect the comparison.
As a result, investors should avoid relying solely on the largest percentage displayed in an investment offer.
What matters is the return you can reasonably expect after considering the investment’s structure, risks, costs and your financial objectives.
Five questions to ask before comparing investment returns
Before committing funds, investors should be able to answer several important questions about the investment being considered.
1. What exactly does the quoted rate represent?
Is it a fixed interest rate, a yield to maturity, a projected return or historical fund performance? These figures are not interchangeable, and each provides different information.
2. Is the return fixed or variable?
Understand whether the rate is contractually specified, subject to periodic changes or dependent on market performance.
3. What risks accompany the potential return?
Consider credit risk, market risk, liquidity risk, currency exposure and the possibility of losing some or all of the invested capital.
4. How and when will I receive my money?
Review maturity dates, income payment schedules, redemption arrangements and any conditions associated with early withdrawal.
5. What will I actually receive after costs?
Consider applicable fees, charges and taxes, and whether the investment’s expected outcome remains suitable for your objectives.
These questions provide a more useful basis for comparing opportunities than simply choosing the highest advertised rate.
Investment Questions Worth Asking
Understanding investment returns often leads to further questions about how financial markets work and how investors should evaluate opportunities.
Does the CBN determine Treasury bill rates in Nigeria?
The CBN conducts Treasury bill auctions on behalf of the Federal Government and influences the broader interest rate environment through monetary policy. However, yields on Treasury bills are established through the relevant issuance and auction process, including investor bids, allotment decisions and prevailing market conditions. The CBN’s Monetary Policy Rate is not automatically the rate paid on Treasury bills.
What is the difference between an interest rate and an investment yield?
An interest rate generally describes the amount of interest payable under specified terms. Investment yield measures the return relative to an investment’s price or value, according to the applicable calculation. For example, a bond’s coupon rate may remain fixed while its yield changes as its market price moves.
Why do Money Market Fund returns change?
Money Market Funds invest in portfolios of short-term money market and other permitted instruments. Their returns are influenced by the yields earned on underlying investments, changes in market interest rates, portfolio composition and fund expenses. Reported yields may change over time and should not be treated as guaranteed future returns.
Can an investment with a lower return be a better choice?
Yes. An investment offering a lower potential return may be more appropriate if it better matches the investor’s risk tolerance, liquidity needs or investment horizon. Suitability depends on the investor’s circumstances and the role the investment is intended to play within the overall portfolio.
How can investors compare investment returns in Nigeria?
Investors should compare investments using consistent time periods and appropriate return measures. They should also consider whether the quoted figures are gross or net of fees, whether returns are fixed or variable, the risks involved, inflation and any restrictions on accessing funds. Comparing similar investment types is generally more meaningful than comparing headline rates across unrelated products.
The bottom line: Understanding returns leads to better investment decisions
So, who actually decides how much your investment earns?
The answer depends on what you invest in.
For some instruments, contractual terms establish the payments an investor can expect, while market conditions influence the price and yield at which those instruments are acquired.
For others, returns depend on company performance, asset prices and broader financial market developments.
Monetary policy influences the investment environment, while professional investment management decisions can affect how portfolios respond to opportunities and risks within that environment.
Ultimately, no single institution determines every investment return, and no single percentage tells the complete story of an investment opportunity.
The most effective investment decisions begin with understanding not only what an investment may earn, but also why it offers that return, what risks accompany it and whether it supports your financial objectives.
At First Ally Asset Management, we believe informed investing begins with understanding your options.
Explore investment opportunities with First Ally Asset Management
Whether you are evaluating fixed-income investments, reviewing your portfolio or considering new opportunities, understanding the factors that influence investment returns is an important part of making informed decisions.
First Ally Asset Management provides investment management solutions designed to help clients pursue their financial objectives within appropriate investment and risk management frameworks.
Visit First Ally Asset Management or contact sales@first-ally.com to learn more about available investment solutions.

